Summary of New Testament From a Jewish Point of View Class - July 31 and July 17, 2023

-

We skipped studying together on Monday, July 24, 2023, since Jo Ann and Dan’s daughter’s 24th birthday was on July 23 and Jo Ann and Dan wanted to devote their entire Monday to Annabelle since she flew back from Israel to the USA on the 23rd.

This blog post summarizes what we have covered on July 31 and July 17.  Both summaries are written by Dan.   

It’s backwards but…..

I’m going to post July 31st’s summary first.  (Jo Ann, Dan, Steve, Karen, Odette, Merrill, Dave attended)

I Timothy chapter 2

Theme: Role of Women

This chapter is controversial because of its rigid restrictions on what women can do, beside having babies.

No one present in today’s conversation supported these restrictions, which include:

Women must dress not just modestly, but plainly. Evidently men were considered to be incapable of self control.
Women must learn in silence and humility.
Women are forbidden to teach.
Women are forbidden to have authority over men.
Women, again, are instructed to be quiet.

The reason given for these instructions was that because Eve was deceived by the serpent in the garden of Eden, but not Adam (!). 

The oddest statement is that “women will be saved through having children” provided they “persevere” in faith, etc. It does not explain if that means that women will be able to safely survive childbirth through their faith, or if having children is some sort of condition for salvation for women (?).

Those in our group who attend church said their churches sometimes had female pastors, and did not put restrictions on women. 

We had a significant discussion, comparing these instructions for women with the role of women in Orthodox Jewish shuls.
We discussed the virtues of having separate discussion groups for men and women. 

We discussed “cults”, and the simplicity of knowing what to do when one is in a cult: obey the cult leader. 

It was a pleasant, lively discussion. Thanks to all who attended.

July 17, 2023 Summary: 

I Timothy chapter 1

I refer to Paul in my summary, acknowledging that the writer may very well have been someone else.

A lot of our conversation revolved around what was meant in verse 4 by the term “myths”. Robin pointed out that this could refer to Jewish stories, from rabbinic sources. Paul also refers to those who would be “teachers of the law”, going on to say that the law was for gross sinners (murderers of parents, etc). It does not seem to encourage keeping to Jewish law to most people. He has a passage where he talks of what an awful sinner he himself was, and how he was pardoned because he had done it out of ignorance. 

The main theme of this chapter is a concern about false teachers who contradict the “faith”, which here appears to mean a creed, a set of beliefs.

On to chapter 2!

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Summary of New Testament From a Jewish Point of View Class - March 27, 2023

-
Image
Jo Ann was off in Europe the day our class met, so Dan was the host of our meeting. Below is a summary, written by Dan, of what went on: “We had Karen, Steve, Dave, Merrill and Randy and Robin join in today. Robin is recovering from her hip replacement, and Steve’s wife is recovering from a complete knee replacement. We sang our “Old time religion” and Mi Shebeirach as usual. I believe we settled on reading IPeter next week.  We read through chapter 13, and Robin pointed out the many exhortations in the chapter, like the one to visit people who are imprisoned are identical to some Jewish writings. Steve pointed out that Hebrews 27:13 referred to the story of the three visitors to Abraham in Genesis. We were a puzzled about Hebrews 13:10s’ assertion about Christians having an altar that the priests in the temple had no right to eat from. The commentary said this could be the heavenly altar. Dan thought it may refer to communion.  The book as a whole made the argument that for J...
Read more

Summary of New Testament From a Jewish Point of View Class - 3/13/23 and 3/20/23

-
Image
Due to my husband Dan’s mother’s recent death, it’s been more difficult to get these summaries done, so this summary includes two weeks. On Monday, March 13, Jo Ann, Dan, Steve, Karen, Dave, Norky, Merrill, Neil, Robin, and Randy attended.  We were glad to have Robin and Randy back after Robin’s hip replacement surgery. Below is a summary written by Dan of what went on on Monday, 3/13/23: We read Hebrews chapter 10, as well as some of the commentary from the Jewish Annotated New Testament.  As the chapter began, the author spoke of the “good things” that Jesus did that “The law” could not do, namely solve the problem of sin, “once and for all”. The author argued that the blood of animals  could not truly take away sin, because if animal blood sacrifice took sin away,  sinners would not feel guilty for their sins anymore. Because people had to keep coming back to sacrifice, it must not take away sin at all. Following that is a discussion about Jesus that seemed to imp...
Read more

Summary of New Testament From Jewish Point of View Class - January 30, 2023

-
Image
Our class was as lively and as fun as always!  Jo Ann, Dan, Ruth, Dave, Karen, Odette, Merrill, Norky, Neil, and Diann attended.  We missed Steve, David, Randy, Robin, Jessica, Kim, Patricia, and Jay and a few others that attend once in a while. Below is a summary written by Dan of what we discussed: We read Revelation chapters 21 and 22, and finished the book of Revelation. Jo Ann brought to our attention how part of the passage comprise part of the Hallelujah Chorus from Handel’s’ Messiah. This passage describes the revelation of the new heaven and new earth, and the idea of eternity in a New Jerusalem where God and the Lamb (Jesus)  dwell with humankind. Forever. A couple of points: 1. The New Jerusalem lacks a temple, saying that the presence of God and the Lamb will be in place of the temple. This contrasts with the Book of Ezekiel, which describes a temple in the world to come. According to the Annotated New Testament some Christian interpreters say this is because ...
Read more